CEJA Examines the Challenges of Regulating the Digital Environment for Children and Adolescents

The debate over how to regulate children’s and adolescents’ access to social media poses significant challenges for legal systems: how can their protection in digital environments be ensured while recognizing their evolving capacities to exercise rights and make decisions? 

This was one of the central questions addressed by Kevin Gutiérrez Parra, a researcher at the Justice Studies Center of the Americas (CEJA), during the First National Conference on the Rights of Children and Adolescents, held on November 4 and 5 and organized by the Department of Private Law at the University of Chile. 

The researcher participated as a speaker on Thursday, November 5, in Session 7C, with a presentation entitled “Social Media Regulation and Evolving Capacities: International Experience, Risks, and Challenges.” 

Gutiérrez presented a comparative overview of measures adopted or under consideration in different countries to regulate children’s and adolescents’ access to digital platforms. 

The presentation identified a global trend: more than 20 countries have proposed or adopted age-based restrictions on access to social media. The regulatory models examined included those of the United Kingdom, Australia, and Brazil. It also explored the tensions between general prohibitions and the principle of evolving capacities, which recognizes children’s and adolescents’ ability to exercise their rights in accordance with their age and maturity. 

The Australian Case and the Limits of Restrictions

One of the examples examined was Australia, where 4.7 million accounts were deactivated during the first month of implementation of the regulation. However, data presented for the first three months showed that a significant proportion of children under the age of 16 continued using the platforms, creating new accounts or circumventing access controls. 

It was also reported that 26% of children between the ages of 13 and 15 continued to use TikTok, just one percentage point lower than before the measure came into effect. 

These findings raise questions about the ability of age-based restrictions to reduce digital risks, particularly when they are not accompanied by additional measures for prevention, oversight, and platform accountability. 

Chile: The Debate Between Protection and Evolving Capacities

The presentation also addressed the legislative debate in Chile, where the National Plan for Safe Digital Environments and various legislative proposals have brought forward measures such as age verification and restrictions on social media access for minors between the ages of 14 and 16. 

In this context, Gutiérrez examined the tensions that may arise between general prohibitions and the principle of evolving capacities, as recognized in Article 11 of Chile’s Law No. 21,430. 

This principle establishes that children and adolescents exercise their rights in accordance with the development of their capacities, their age, and their maturity, seeking to strike a balance between autonomy and protection. 

Toward Gradual Regulatory Approaches and Effective Protection

As part of his preliminary conclusions, Gutiérrez highlighted the importance of considering gradual regulatory approaches that incorporate age-verification mechanisms, tiered parental consent, age-appropriate safety-by-design measures, and algorithmic transparency. 

The central message of his presentation was that protection in digital environments should not be limited to restricting access. It should also seek to prevent harmful uses of digital platforms and ensure the progressive exercise of children’s and adolescents’ rights. 

Noticias relacionadas:

The Federal Institute of Public Defense (Instituto Federal de Defensoría Pública – IFDP) and the Justice Studies Center of the Americas (Centro de Estudios de Justicia de las Américas – CEJA) have signed a Memorandum of Understanding to promote research, training, and joint initiatives aimed at reducing inequalities and strengthening access to justice for priority groups.
The debate over how to regulate children’s and adolescents’ access to social media poses significant challenges for legal systems: how can their protection in digital environments be ensured while recognizing their evolving capacities to exercise rights and make decisions? 
The Justice Studies Center of the Americas (CEJA/JSCA) is launching a participatory process to define the priorities that will guide its work over the next four years. We want to hear from those who wish to contribute with their perspectives and experiences on justice in the region. 
The Justice Studies Center of the Americas (CEJA) and the Master’s Program in Law (LLM UC) at the Faculty of Law of the Pontifical Catholic University of Chile have signed a framework cooperation agreement aimed at strengthening academic research, student training, and the development of joint initiatives focused on the reform and modernization of justice systems across the region.
At the 56th General Assembly of the Organization of American States (OAS), the Member States elected Patricia Elizabeth Gámez (Guatemala) and Santiago Pereira Campos (Uruguay) as new members of the Board of Directors of the Justice Studies Center of the Americas (CEJA/JSCA).